Is the organized crime the last line of defense of conservatism?
Part 1
One could argue that the older the criminal ideology is, the more conservative it also is.
Even if that is not the case, we must accept that organized crime lives and acts through codes and behavior systems, which are supervised at least to some point, and also violated egotistically by the individual in power. There has to be a couple of components so that the ideology can persist in time and preserve the same structures that the formal installations increasingly struggle to maintain. There has to be tradition, territory, hierarchical structures, social order and at least some resistance to change.
What I realized during my ten prison years was that the changing process was so demanding that most of the convicts just didn't want to go through it and accepted the same old way. The conservatism always appeared when some new idea or way to behave entered the space that only inmates share. One can imagine that, for example, being gay in those places isn't a thing that will add respect to one's resume. For example, in Brazilian communities where Comando Vermelho operates, an order was given a few months ago that "a man is a man and a woman is a woman," period. No woke party stood against it, even though it was made public. When the contrary opinion is holding an assault rifle and is surrounded by juvenile serial killers, for sure it is challenging to maintain an opposite point of view.
We have to respect the freedom to think and form any opinion one wishes, but we shouldn't respect every opinion. This takes us deep into some of the most trivial paradoxes of life. And it provokes us to think about the many faces of life itself. But what matters in the end, when the conventional distinction of legitimate power and illegitimate power comes in touch with a particular human destiny? When it is the time of the decision about whose mother is going to cry, ours or the others'?
It can be seen, or at least suggested, that organized crime can reveal something about how political, economic and social power actually operates. Although the interesting paradox here is that organized crime can be revolutionary in its methods while deeply conservative in its values, we cannot close our eyes to the fact that the laws are never made by the poor. And crime is the only sociological organ that can reject the state's authority without rejecting the concept of authority itself. Power is in the hands of its holder. It can be abused much more easily than used for good. And this is what I saw occurring repeatedly. The lower levels of power have no idea about what goes on at the next superior level, and even less about the higher levels. To operate with a type of power that has the authority to take lives could be the saddest profession on this planet, except for psychopaths.
However, organized crime isn't necessarily ideologically conservative. It can be opportunistic, commercially and egotistically driven, and even self-stabilizing to maintain power, and also destabilizing to its own traditional values and institutions. If we dig a little bit deeper, we can interpret that conservatism is not necessarily about morality or legality; it can also be about preserving existing hierarchical structures and power relationships. We always wind up on the same old route of proud selfishness, which takes us to greed that is tempered with gluttony and hate.
Even though some of the most honest rules of conduct came from criminals, we have to admit that we all enjoy some benefits of the criminal movements in our everyday lives in some sort of way through historical happenings. The starters of any revolution are seen as criminals, which they often also honestly are, but what some of them have accomplished is right now in our use. The American Revolution established a political order based on independence and constitutional government. The Haitian Revolution of the slaves created the first independent black republic. The French Revolution challenged the established political order and transformed ideas about citizenship and sovereignty. The American civil rights movement deliberately violated segregation laws through civil disobedience, accepting arrests to challenge discriminatory legislation. The list goes on and on.
The uncomfortable relationship of law and power brings us in front of the same old questions: Is the underlying system fair? Is the authority morally or politically justified? Does the existing authority permit it? In a maximum security penitentiary, the same flaws of personality can be found just as in the supreme courts around the world. Both of them have the power and the authority to decide about life.
Obviously, other forces and movements, like philosophical and enlightenment thinkers with religious and humanitarian traditions, have played a huge role in revolutions also, and as we look further into the subject, we can see that the problem is not perhaps the power itself, just as it is that there is no responsibility in the gun or in money. Both of them just bring out of us who we really are when either one is suddenly being added drastically. The same thing happens many times with power, eventually.
The deeper paradox is that conservatism is what protects the laws and boundaries of legality, which are determined and defined by the government, which may itself have acquired power through rebellion, revolution, conquest or coercion. Studying history tells us factually that when a revolutionary movement succeeds, yesterday's criminals can become tomorrow's founding fathers and mothers. And yesterday's legal authorities can become tomorrow's historical examples of injustice.
If you read until here, you already are one of the few.
My course "Inside out" handles our inner conflicts that we all face during our lives. Start your own substantial transformation even if don't feel ready.





Comments